Teachers on TV? Schools Try Creative Strategy to Narrow Digital Divide
It’s another way to reach students without internet or computers during the pandemic.
Melinda Spaulding Chevalier, a former TV anchor, got Houston’s Fox station to air a program featuring local teachers. Her children are Felix Chevalier II, left, and Landon Joy Chevalier.Credit...Brandon Thibodeaux for The New York Times
By Kellen Browning
Jan. 3, 2021, 3:14 p.m. ET
Nearly every weekday morning, Valentin Vivar curls up in bed next to his older sister, Araceli, and switches on one of his favorite television shows.
The hourlong program, “ Let’s Learn NYC! ”, isn’t typical children’s fare. Valentin, 5, watches as educators from New York City public schools teach math and science, sing songs and take viewers on virtual field trips to botanical gardens and dance performances. Araceli, 17, is there to help out.
After the coronavirus pandemic shut down their schools in March, the siblings attended virtual classes from their apartment in Queens on Araceli’s iPhone. Their parents could not afford another device, and their class attendance was sporadic because sometimes both had school at the same time. Valentin, who needed speech therapy, was missing out on conversations with classmates, and he was struggling to pronounce words.
Then a teacher told them about the television program, and Valentin was hooked. He sounded out letters and words and formed strong bonds with the teachers he saw onscreen.
Now, Valentin “wants to read books by himself, and he’s writing new words,” Araceli said. “I really like to see him learn and grow.”
Around the country, educators and local television stations have teamed up to help teachers make their broadcast debuts and engage children who are stuck in the doldrums of distance learning. The idea — in some ways a throwback to the early days of public television — has supplemented online lessons for some families, and serves a more critical role: reaching students who, without reliable internet access or a laptop at home, have been left behind.
In some places, the programs air on weekends or after school. Elsewhere, districts have scheduled time to watch it during the school day. In New York, the program airs every weekday on a public television channel, part of a network of PBS stations working with school districts.
Fox stations in several cities are airing teachers’ lessons as well, thanks to Melinda Spaulding Chevalier, a Houston resident and former TV news anchor who thought of the concept in March. She pitched a daily program featuring teachers to her old boss, D’Artagnan Bebel, the general manager of Houston’s Fox station. He was in.
Less than two weeks later, local educators were on the air, teaching condensed lessons for an hour.
The concept quickly spread to Fox stations in Chicago, San Francisco and Washington, all of which joined with local school districts or teacher unions to put teachers on television. (The initiative ended in Houston and Washington after the spring but is still airing every weekday in San Francisco and on Saturdays in Chicago.)
In Houston, an average of 37,000 people watched the program each time it aired in the spring, and about 2,200 people were watching the San Francisco version each day this fall, the TV stations said. “ We Still Teach ,” the Chicago version of the program, which began in May, reaches 50,000 households in the area each weekend, according to Nielsen.
“We’re not solving the digital divide, but from my experience with the personal connection of coming into a viewer’s kitchen or living room, I felt this could be a more immediate way to help bridge the gap,” Ms. Spaulding Chevalier said. “We’re letting them know they haven’t been forgotten.”
The divide in education between families that can afford laptops and strong Wi-Fi signals and those that can’t has been well documented , and often affects rural areas and communities of color. In 2018, 15 million to 16 million students didn’t have an adequate device or reliable internet connection at home, according to a report from Common Sense Media , a children’s advocacy and media ratings group that receives licensing fees from internet providers that distribute its content.
The gap between the haves and the have-nots has been exacerbated by school shutdowns. As recently as October, at least thousands of students in the United States were still unable to join remote classrooms because they had no access to a laptop . But 96 percent of Americans were estimated to have a working television set, according to Nielsen .
Ms. Spaulding Chevalier’s sister, Tamika Spaulding, who produces the Chicago version of the program with her friend Katherine O’Brien, said they had acted with urgency.
“There are a lot of plans to address the digital divide, but they have four-year rollout plans,” Ms. Spaulding said. “So what are you doing for the student today, right now, who’s just not getting educational content?”
The plan was embraced by hundreds of educators who agreed to set up tripods in their living rooms, assemble makeshift props, send in footage and make their broadcast debuts. Some of their content is aimed at younger children, and other segments target high school ages.
Erik Young, a high school social studies teacher in Chicago, appears in “We Still Teach.”Credit...Fox32
Erik Young, a high school social studies teacher in Chicago, said he had jumped at the chance to provide extra help to students stuck at home.
“It was needed for lots of us,” he said. “In addition to us missing our students and our school family, you really do miss the camaraderie.”
Mr. Young filmed a series of social studies quiz shows and cheesy history poetry in his basement on his daughter’s iPhone, starting over whenever he stumbled over a line. His efforts epitomized what the show’s creators consider one of the program’s most endearing characteristics — a grass-roots, rough-around-the-edges quality.
“This is what we do — creating something out of nothing is quintessentially what it feels like to be a Chicago Public Schools educator,” said Stacy Davis Gates, the vice president of the Chicago Teachers Union.
The Fox stations are airing the educational program for free, without requiring districts to pay for airtime and without running commercials. Future Chicago broadcasts are dependent on whether the creators continue producing it.
Educators say the program has helped children form deep connections with the teachers they see onscreen — a classroom type of relationship that is tough to reproduce through remote learning.
“There are no frustrating tech disruptions,” Ms. Spaulding Chevalier said, explaining why children are often more drawn to the teachers on TV than on a computer screen. “Students are able to focus on the lesson, on a larger screen, and with a medium that’s comfortable.”
Some 15 million American schoolchildren lack reliable internet. One solution: Wi-Fi buses that bring school to students .
In San Francisco, Latoya Pitcher’s 4-year-old son, Levi, is a devoted fan of the program, and loves to sing its daily goodbye song along with the school district’s superintendent, Vincent Matthews. The one time Ms. Pitcher forgot to turn on the program, she said, Levi asked: “Mommy, what happened to my friend?”
“They have Dora and ‘Blues Clues’ and all that, but this is people,” Ms. Pitcher said. “That’s what they lost with shelter-in-place: seeing people every day.”
Public television stations have worked out similar partnerships with educators in at least 15 states, according to America’s Public Television Stations, a nonprofit organization that coordinates with local stations.
Melissa Good, a sixth-grade teacher in the mountain community of Montrose, Colo., said she was nervous about teaching writing skills on TV. But she did it anyway for Rocky Mountain PBS’ program because, she said, she has seen the learning deterioration that takes place when children lack internet at home.
“It’s incredibly disheartening to watch the kids feel like they’re drowning at home,” she said.
Chiara Grey, a Montrose resident, could not afford internet in the spring, so her son Connor, 9, did not attend online classes and missed out on several months of education.
“That big, huge gap was a pretty detrimental thing,” Ms. Grey said. Through the PBS program, Connor learned how to write a paragraph over the summer, and caught up on some of the lost time.
“We were really thrown into this parenting-slash-teaching role, and I don’t know how to do those things,” Ms. Grey said. “So having somebody who knows how to show me or tell me, ‘This is what you do,’ that was really helpful.”
In New York, fall education has fluctuated between remote and in person, but the Vivar siblings have remained at home because of concerns about the coronavirus. Valentin, a kindergartner, got an iPad from the school district in September, so he can attend remote classes, but he still watches the TV program.
Araceli, a high school senior, has struggled to keep up with assignments and college applications while also ensuring her brother is getting an education. When Valentin is watching the television program, she said, she can focus on her studies and know that he is being taken care of.
“Whenever he sees the program, he gets happy,” Araceli said. “It’s good for him to know that there’s another teacher in the TV for him.”